Add option to include interval start/end markup on extract

When enabled, lines like "# interval-start 1234567890123456" and "#
interval-end 1234567890123456" will be added to the data output.  Note
that there may be an "interval-end" timestamp followed by an identical
"interval-start" timestamp, if the response at the nilmdb level was
split up into multiple chunks.

In general, assume contiguous data if previous_interval_end ==
new_interval_start.

extras/nilmtool-bash-completion.sh

@@ -17,4 +17,4 @@ _nilmtool_argcomplete() {
         unset COMPREPLY
     fi
 }
-complete -o nospace -o default -F _nilmtool_argcomplete nilmtool
+complete -o nospace -F _nilmtool_argcomplete nilmtool

nilmdb/client/client.py

@@ -97,7 +97,7 @@ class Client(object):
         return self.http.post("stream/create", params)
 
     def stream_destroy(self, path):
-        """Delete stream and its contents"""
+        """Delete stream.  Fails if any data is still present."""
         params = { "path": path }
         return self.http.post("stream/destroy", params)
 
@@ -171,7 +171,8 @@ class Client(object):
             params["end"] = timestamp_to_string(end)
         return self.http.get_gen("stream/intervals", params)
 
-    def stream_extract(self, path, start = None, end = None, count = False):
+    def stream_extract(self, path, start = None, end = None,
+                       count = False, markup = False):
         """
         Extract data from a stream.  Returns a generator that yields
         lines of ASCII-formatted data that matches the database
@@ -179,6 +180,9 @@ class Client(object):
 
         Specify count = True to return a count of matching data points
         rather than the actual data.  The output format is unchanged.
+
+        Specify markup = True to include comments in the returned data
+        that indicate interval starts and ends.
         """
         params = {
             "path": path,
@@ -189,6 +193,8 @@ class Client(object):
             params["end"] = timestamp_to_string(end)
         if count:
             params["count"] = 1
+        if markup:
+            params["markup"] = 1
         return self.http.get_gen("stream/extract", params)
 
     def stream_count(self, path, start = None, end = None):

nilmdb/cmdline/destroy.py

@@ -7,11 +7,14 @@ def setup(self, sub):
     cmd = sub.add_parser("destroy", help="Delete a stream and all data",
                          formatter_class = def_form,
                          description="""
-                         Destroy the stream at the specified path.  All
+                         Destroy the stream at the specified path.
-                         data and metadata related to the stream is
+                         The stream must be empty.  All metadata
-                         permanently deleted.
+                         related to the stream is permanently deleted.
                          """)
     cmd.set_defaults(handler = cmd_destroy)
+    group = cmd.add_argument_group("Options")
+    group.add_argument("-R", "--remove", action="store_true",
+                       help="Remove all data before destroying stream")
     group = cmd.add_argument_group("Required arguments")
     group.add_argument("path",
                        help="Path of the stream to delete, e.g. /foo/bar",
@@ -20,6 +23,11 @@ def setup(self, sub):
 
 def cmd_destroy(self):
     """Destroy stream"""
+    if self.args.remove:
+        try:
+            count = self.client.stream_remove(self.args.path)
+        except nilmdb.client.ClientError as e:
+            self.die("error removing data: %s", str(e))
     try:
         self.client.stream_destroy(self.args.path)
     except nilmdb.client.ClientError as e:

nilmdb/cmdline/extract.py

@@ -29,6 +29,8 @@ def setup(self, sub):
     group.add_argument("-a", "--annotate", action="store_true",
                        help="Include comments with some information "
                        "about the stream")
+    group.add_argument("-m", "--markup", action="store_true",
+                       help="Include comments with interval starts and ends")
     group.add_argument("-T", "--timestamp-raw", action="store_true",
                        help="Show raw timestamps in annotated information")
     group.add_argument("-c", "--count", action="store_true",
@@ -61,7 +63,8 @@ def cmd_extract(self):
     for dataline in self.client.stream_extract(self.args.path,
                                                self.args.start,
                                                self.args.end,
-                                               self.args.count):
+                                               self.args.count,
+                                               self.args.markup):
         if self.args.bare and not self.args.count:
             # Strip timestamp (first element).  Doesn't make sense
             # if we are only returning a count.

nilmdb/server/interval.pyx

@@ -286,22 +286,17 @@ cdef class IntervalSet:
         (potentially) subsetted to make the one that is being
         returned.
         """
-        if not isinstance(interval, Interval):
+        if orig:
-            raise TypeError("bad type")
             for n in self.tree.intersect(interval.start, interval.end):
                 i = n.obj
-            if i:
-                if i.start >= interval.start and i.end <= interval.end:
-                    if orig:
-                        yield (i, i)
-                    else:
-                        yield i
-                else:
                 subset = i.subset(max(i.start, interval.start),
                                   min(i.end, interval.end))
-                    if orig:
                 yield (subset, i)
         else:
+            for n in self.tree.intersect(interval.start, interval.end):
+                i = n.obj
+                subset = i.subset(max(i.start, interval.start),
+                                  min(i.end, interval.end))
                 yield subset
 
     cpdef intersects(self, Interval other):

nilmdb/server/nilmdb.py

@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ Manages both the SQL database and the table storage backend.
 from __future__ import absolute_import
 import nilmdb.utils
 from nilmdb.utils.printf import *
+from nilmdb.utils.time import timestamp_to_string
 
 from nilmdb.utils.interval import IntervalError
 from nilmdb.server.interval import Interval, DBInterval, IntervalSet
@@ -83,7 +84,18 @@ class NilmDB(object):
     verbose = 0
 
     def __init__(self, basepath, max_results=None,
-                 bulkdata_args=None):
+                 max_removals=None, bulkdata_args=None):
+        """Initialize NilmDB at the given basepath.
+        Other arguments are for debugging / testing:
+
+        'max_results' is the max rows to send in a single
+        stream_intervals or stream_extract response.
+
+        'max_removals' is the max rows to delete at once
+        in stream_move.
+
+        'bulkdata_args' is kwargs for the bulkdata module.
+        """
         if bulkdata_args is None:
             bulkdata_args = {}
 
@@ -113,11 +125,11 @@ class NilmDB(object):
         self.con.execute("PRAGMA journal_mode=WAL")
 
         # Approximate largest number of elements that we want to send
-        # in a single reply (for stream_intervals, stream_extract)
+        # in a single reply (for stream_intervals, stream_extract).
-        if max_results:
+        self.max_results = max_results or 16384
-            self.max_results = max_results
+
-        else:
+        # Remove up to this many rows per call to stream_remove.
-            self.max_results = 16384
+        self.max_removals = max_removals or 1048576
 
     def get_basepath(self):
         return self.basepath
@@ -334,14 +346,14 @@ class NilmDB(object):
 
         Returns (intervals, restart) tuple.
 
-        intervals is a list of [start,end] timestamps of all intervals
+        'intervals' is a list of [start,end] timestamps of all intervals
         that exist for path, between start and end.
 
-        restart, if nonzero, means that there were too many results to
+        'restart', if not None, means that there were too many results
-        return in a single request.  The data is complete from the
+        to return in a single request.  The data is complete from the
-        starting timestamp to the point at which it was truncated,
+        starting timestamp to the point at which it was truncated, and
-        and a new request with a start time of 'restart' will fetch
+        a new request with a start time of 'restart' will fetch the
-        the next block of data.
+        next block of data.
         """
         stream_id = self._stream_id(path)
         intervals = self._get_intervals(stream_id)
@@ -363,7 +375,7 @@ class NilmDB(object):
                 break
             result.append([i.start, i.end])
         else:
-            restart = 0
+            restart = None
         return (result, restart)
 
     def stream_create(self, path, layout_name):
@@ -439,17 +451,22 @@ class NilmDB(object):
                         (newpath, stream_id))
 
     def stream_destroy(self, path):
-        """Fully remove a table and all of its data from the database.
+        """Fully remove a table from the database.  Fails if there are
-        No way to undo it!  Metadata is removed."""
+        any intervals data present; remove them first.  Metadata is
+        also removed."""
         stream_id = self._stream_id(path)
 
-        # Delete the cached interval data (if it was cached)
+        # Verify that no intervals are present, and clear the cache
+        iset = self._get_intervals(stream_id)
+        if len(iset):
+            raise NilmDBError("all intervals must be removed before "
+                              "destroying a stream")
         self._get_intervals.cache_remove(self, stream_id)
 
-        # Delete the data
+        # Delete the bulkdata storage
         self.data.destroy(path)
 
-        # Delete metadata, stream, intervals
+        # Delete metadata, stream, intervals (should be none)
         with self.con as con:
             con.execute("DELETE FROM metadata WHERE stream_id=?", (stream_id,))
             con.execute("DELETE FROM ranges WHERE stream_id=?", (stream_id,))
@@ -517,23 +534,28 @@ class NilmDB(object):
                                   dbinterval.db_startpos,
                                   dbinterval.db_endpos)
 
-    def stream_extract(self, path, start = None, end = None, count = False):
+    def stream_extract(self, path, start = None, end = None,
+                       count = False, markup = False):
         """
         Returns (data, restart) tuple.
 
-        data is ASCII-formatted data from the database, formatted
+        'data' is ASCII-formatted data from the database, formatted
         according to the layout of the stream.
 
-        restart, if nonzero, means that there were too many results to
+        'restart', if not None, means that there were too many results to
         return in a single request.  The data is complete from the
         starting timestamp to the point at which it was truncated,
         and a new request with a start time of 'restart' will fetch
         the next block of data.
 
-        count, if true, means to not return raw data, but just the count
+        'count', if true, means to not return raw data, but just the count
         of rows that would have been returned.  This is much faster
         than actually fetching the data.  It is not limited by
         max_results.
+
+        'markup', if true, indicates that returned data should be
+        marked with a comment denoting when a particular interval
+        starts, and another comment when an interval ends.
         """
         stream_id = self._stream_id(path)
         table = self.data.getnode(path)
@@ -543,7 +565,7 @@ class NilmDB(object):
         result = []
         matched = 0
         remaining = self.max_results
-        restart = 0
+        restart = None
         for interval in intervals.intersection(requested):
             # Reading single rows from the table is too slow, so
             # we use two bisections to find both the starting and
@@ -562,14 +584,26 @@ class NilmDB(object):
                 row_end = row_max
                 restart = table[row_max]
 
+            # Add markup
+            if markup:
+                result.append("# interval-start " +
+                              timestamp_to_string(interval.start) + "\n")
+
             # Gather these results up
             result.append(table.get_data(row_start, row_end))
 
             # Count them
             remaining -= row_end - row_start
 
-            if restart:
+            # Add markup, and exit if restart is set.
+            if restart is not None:
+                if markup:
+                    result.append("# interval-end " +
+                                  timestamp_to_string(restart) + "\n")
                 break
+            if markup:
+                result.append("# interval-end " +
+                              timestamp_to_string(interval.end) + "\n")
 
         if count:
             return matched
@@ -578,9 +612,17 @@ class NilmDB(object):
     def stream_remove(self, path, start = None, end = None):
         """
         Remove data from the specified time interval within a stream.
-        Removes all data in the interval [start, end), and intervals
+
-        are truncated or split appropriately.  Returns the number of
+        Removes data in the interval [start, end), and intervals are
-        data points removed.
+        truncated or split appropriately.
+
+        Returns a (removed, restart) tuple.
+
+        'removed' is the number of data points that were removed.
+
+        'restart', if not None, means there were too many rows to
+        remove in a single request.  This function should be called
+        again with a start time of 'restart' to complete the removal.
         """
         stream_id = self._stream_id(path)
         table = self.data.getnode(path)
@@ -588,6 +630,8 @@ class NilmDB(object):
         (start, end) = self._check_user_times(start, end)
         to_remove = Interval(start, end)
         removed = 0
+        remaining = self.max_removals
+        restart = None
 
         # Can't remove intervals from within the iterator, so we need to
         # remember what's currently in the intersection now.
@@ -598,6 +642,13 @@ class NilmDB(object):
             row_start = self._find_start(table, dbint)
             row_end = self._find_end(table, dbint)
 
+            # Shorten it if we'll hit the maximum number of removals
+            row_max = row_start + remaining
+            if row_max < row_end:
+                row_end = row_max
+                dbint.end = table[row_max]
+                restart = dbint.end
+
             # Adjust the DBInterval to match the newly found ends
             dbint.db_start = dbint.start
             dbint.db_end = dbint.end
@@ -613,4 +664,7 @@ class NilmDB(object):
             # Count how many were removed
             removed += row_end - row_start
 
-        return removed
+            if restart is not None:
+                break
+
+        return (removed, restart)

nilmdb/server/server.py

@@ -210,7 +210,7 @@ class Stream(NilmApp):
     @exception_to_httperror(NilmDBError)
     @cherrypy.tools.CORS_allow(methods = ["POST"])
     def destroy(self, path):
-        """Delete a stream and its associated data."""
+        """Delete a stream.  Fails if any data is still present."""
         return self.db.stream_destroy(path)
 
     # /stream/rename?oldpath=/newton/prep&newpath=/newton/prep/1
@@ -339,7 +339,14 @@ class Stream(NilmApp):
             if start >= end:
                 raise cherrypy.HTTPError("400 Bad Request",
                                          "start must precede end")
-        return self.db.stream_remove(path, start, end)
+        total_removed = 0
+        while True:
+            (removed, restart) = self.db.stream_remove(path, start, end)
+            total_removed += removed
+            if restart is None:
+                break
+            start = restart
+        return total_removed
 
     # /stream/intervals?path=/newton/prep
     # /stream/intervals?path=/newton/prep&start=1234567890.0&end=1234567899.0
@@ -386,7 +393,7 @@ class Stream(NilmApp):
                                                            diffpath)
                 response = ''.join([ json.dumps(i) + "\r\n" for i in ints ])
                 yield response
-                if restart == 0:
+                if restart is None:
                     break
                 start = restart
         return content(start, end)
@@ -395,14 +402,18 @@ class Stream(NilmApp):
     @cherrypy.expose
     @chunked_response
     @response_type("text/plain")
-    def extract(self, path, start = None, end = None, count = False):
+    def extract(self, path, start = None, end = None,
+                count = False, markup = False):
         """
         Extract data from backend database.  Streams the resulting
         entries as ASCII text lines separated by newlines.  This may
         make multiple requests to the nilmdb backend to avoid causing
         it to block for too long.
 
-        Add count=True to return a count rather than actual data.
+        If 'count' is True, returns a count rather than actual data.
+
+        If 'markup' is True, adds comments to the stream denoting each
+        interval's start and end timestamp.
         """
         if start is not None:
             start = string_to_timestamp(start)
@@ -421,21 +432,23 @@ class Stream(NilmApp):
             raise cherrypy.HTTPError("404 Not Found", "No such stream")
 
         @workaround_cp_bug_1200
-        def content(start, end, count):
+        def content(start, end):
             # Note: disable chunked responses to see tracebacks from here.
             if count:
-                matched = self.db.stream_extract(path, start, end, count)
+                matched = self.db.stream_extract(path, start, end,
+                                                 count = True)
                 yield sprintf("%d\n", matched)
                 return
 
             while True:
-                (data, restart) = self.db.stream_extract(path, start, end)
+                (data, restart) = self.db.stream_extract(
+                    path, start, end, count = False, markup = markup)
                 yield data
 
-                if restart == 0:
+                if restart is None:
                     return
                 start = restart
-        return content(start, end, count)
+        return content(start, end)
 
 class Exiter(object):
     """App that exits the server, for testing"""

nilmdb/utils/time.py

@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
+from __future__ import absolute_import
+
 from nilmdb.utils import datetime_tz
 import re
 import time
@@ -58,6 +60,11 @@ def parse_time(toparse):
     timestamp, the current local timezone is assumed (e.g. from the TZ
     env var).
     """
+    if toparse == "min":
+        return min_timestamp
+    if toparse == "max":
+        return max_timestamp
+
     # If string isn't "now" and doesn't contain at least 4 digits,
     # consider it invalid.  smartparse might otherwise accept
     # empty strings and strings with just separators.

tests/data/extract-8

@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
+# interval-start 1332496919900000
+1332496919900000 2.523050e+05 2.254020e+05 4.779410e+03 3.638030e+03 8.138070e+03 4.334460e+03 1.083780e+03 3.743730e+03
+1332496919908333 2.551190e+05 2.237870e+05 5.965640e+03 2.076350e+03 9.468790e+03 3.693880e+03 1.247860e+03 3.393680e+03
+1332496919916667 2.616370e+05 2.247980e+05 4.848970e+03 2.315620e+03 9.323300e+03 4.225460e+03 1.805780e+03 2.593050e+03
+1332496919925000 2.606460e+05 2.251300e+05 3.061360e+03 3.951840e+03 7.662910e+03 5.341410e+03 1.986520e+03 2.276780e+03
+1332496919933333 2.559710e+05 2.235030e+05 4.096030e+03 3.296970e+03 7.827080e+03 5.452120e+03 2.492520e+03 2.929450e+03
+1332496919941667 2.579260e+05 2.217080e+05 5.472320e+03 1.555700e+03 8.495760e+03 4.491140e+03 2.379780e+03 3.741710e+03
+1332496919950000 2.610180e+05 2.242350e+05 4.669770e+03 1.876190e+03 8.366680e+03 3.677510e+03 9.021690e+02 3.549040e+03
+1332496919958333 2.569150e+05 2.274650e+05 2.785070e+03 3.751930e+03 7.440320e+03 3.964860e+03 -3.227860e+02 2.460890e+03
+1332496919966667 2.509510e+05 2.262000e+05 3.772710e+03 3.131950e+03 8.159860e+03 4.539860e+03 7.375190e+02 2.126750e+03
+1332496919975000 2.556710e+05 2.223720e+05 5.826200e+03 8.715560e+02 9.120240e+03 4.545110e+03 2.804310e+03 2.721000e+03
+1332496919983333 2.649730e+05 2.214860e+05 5.839130e+03 4.659180e+02 8.628300e+03 3.934870e+03 2.972490e+03 3.773730e+03
+1332496919991667 2.652170e+05 2.233920e+05 3.718770e+03 2.834970e+03 7.209900e+03 3.460260e+03 1.324930e+03 4.075960e+03
+# interval-end 1332496919991668
+# interval-start 1332496920000000
+1332496920000000 2.564370e+05 2.244300e+05 4.011610e+03 3.475340e+03 7.495890e+03 3.388940e+03 2.613970e+02 3.731260e+03
+1332496920008333 2.539630e+05 2.241670e+05 5.621070e+03 1.548010e+03 9.165170e+03 3.522930e+03 1.058930e+03 2.996960e+03
+1332496920016667 2.585080e+05 2.249300e+05 6.011400e+03 8.188660e+02 9.039950e+03 4.482440e+03 2.490390e+03 2.679340e+03
+1332496920025000 2.596270e+05 2.260220e+05 4.474500e+03 2.423020e+03 7.414190e+03 5.071970e+03 2.439380e+03 2.962960e+03
+1332496920033333 2.551870e+05 2.246320e+05 4.738570e+03 3.398040e+03 7.395120e+03 4.726450e+03 1.839030e+03 3.393530e+03
+1332496920041667 2.571020e+05 2.216230e+05 6.144130e+03 1.441090e+03 8.756480e+03 3.495320e+03 1.869940e+03 3.752530e+03
+1332496920050000 2.636530e+05 2.217700e+05 6.221770e+03 7.389620e+02 9.547600e+03 2.666820e+03 1.462660e+03 3.332570e+03
+1332496920058333 2.636130e+05 2.252560e+05 4.477120e+03 2.437450e+03 8.510210e+03 3.855630e+03 9.594420e+02 2.387180e+03
+1332496920066667 2.553500e+05 2.262640e+05 4.283720e+03 3.923940e+03 7.912470e+03 5.466520e+03 1.284990e+03 2.093720e+03
+1332496920075000 2.527270e+05 2.246090e+05 5.851930e+03 2.491980e+03 8.540630e+03 5.623050e+03 2.339780e+03 3.007140e+03
+1332496920083333 2.584750e+05 2.235780e+05 5.924870e+03 1.394480e+03 8.779620e+03 4.544180e+03 2.132030e+03 3.849760e+03
+1332496920091667 2.615630e+05 2.246090e+05 4.336140e+03 2.455750e+03 8.055380e+03 3.469110e+03 6.278730e+02 3.664200e+03
+# interval-end 1332496920100000

tests/test_client.py

@@ -375,6 +375,7 @@ class TestClient(object):
 
             # Delete streams that exist
             for stream in client.stream_list():
+                client.stream_remove(stream[0])
                 client.stream_destroy(stream[0])
 
             # Database is empty
@@ -506,6 +507,10 @@ class TestClient(object):
               [ 109, 118 ],
               [ 200, 300 ] ])
 
+        # destroy stream (try without removing data first)
+        with assert_raises(ClientError):
+            client.stream_destroy("/context/test")
+        client.stream_remove("/context/test")
         client.stream_destroy("/context/test")
         client.close()
 
@@ -600,6 +605,7 @@ class TestClient(object):
                      ])
 
         # Clean up
+        client.stream_remove("/empty/test")
         client.stream_destroy("/empty/test")
         client.close()
 
@@ -635,8 +641,9 @@ class TestClient(object):
             eq_(connections(), (1, 5))
 
             # Clean up
+            c.stream_remove("/persist/test")
             c.stream_destroy("/persist/test")
-            eq_(connections(), (1, 6))
+            eq_(connections(), (1, 7))
 
     def test_client_13_timestamp_rounding(self):
         # Test potentially bad timestamps (due to floating point
@@ -661,5 +668,6 @@ class TestClient(object):
                 # Server will round this and give an error on finalize()
                 ctx.insert("299999999.99 1\n")
 
+        client.stream_remove("/rounding/test")
         client.stream_destroy("/rounding/test")
         client.close()

tests/test_cmdline.py

@@ -21,12 +21,13 @@ from testutil.helpers import *
 
 testdb = "tests/cmdline-testdb"
 
-def server_start(max_results = None, bulkdata_args = {}):
+def server_start(max_results = None, max_removals = None, bulkdata_args = {}):
     global test_server, test_db
     # Start web app on a custom port
     test_db = nilmdb.utils.serializer_proxy(nilmdb.server.NilmDB)(
         testdb,
         max_results = max_results,
+        max_removals = max_removals,
         bulkdata_args = bulkdata_args)
     test_server = nilmdb.server.Server(test_db, host = "127.0.0.1",
                                        port = 32180, stoppable = False,
@@ -233,6 +234,8 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         eq_(parse_time("1333648800.0"), test)
         eq_(parse_time("1333648800000000"), test)
         eq_(parse_time("@1333648800000000"), test)
+        eq_(parse_time("min"), nilmdb.utils.time.min_timestamp)
+        eq_(parse_time("max"), nilmdb.utils.time.max_timestamp)
         with assert_raises(ValueError):
             parse_time("@hashtag12345")
 
@@ -593,6 +596,8 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         test(6, "10:00:30", "10:00:31", extra="-b")
         test(7, "10:00:30", "10:00:30.999", extra="-a -T")
         test(7, "10:00:30", "10:00:30.999", extra="-a --timestamp-raw")
+        test(8, "10:01:59.9", "10:02:00.1", extra="--markup")
+        test(8, "10:01:59.9", "10:02:00.1", extra="-m")
 
         # all data put in by tests
         self.ok("extract -a /newton/prep --start 2000-01-01 --end 2020-01-01")
@@ -600,6 +605,11 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         self.ok("extract -c /newton/prep --start 2000-01-01 --end 2020-01-01")
         self.match("43200\n")
 
+        # markup for 3 intervals, plus extra markup lines whenever we had
+        # a "restart" from the nilmdb.stream_extract function
+        self.ok("extract -m /newton/prep --start 2000-01-01 --end 2020-01-01")
+        lines_(self.captured, 43210)
+
     def test_09_truncated(self):
         # Test truncated responses by overriding the nilmdb max_results
         server_stop()
@@ -699,11 +709,9 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
 
         # Reinsert some data, to verify that no overlaps with deleted
         # data are reported
-        os.environ['TZ'] = "UTC"
+        for minute in ["0", "2"]:
             self.ok("insert --timestamp -f --rate 120 /newton/prep"
-                "tests/data/prep-20120323T1000")
+                    " tests/data/prep-20120323T100" + minute)
-        self.ok("insert -t --filename --rate 120 /newton/prep "
-                "tests/data/prep-20120323T1002")
 
     def test_11_destroy(self):
         # Delete records
@@ -715,6 +723,9 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         self.fail("destroy /no/such/stream")
         self.contain("No stream at path")
 
+        self.fail("destroy -R /no/such/stream")
+        self.contain("No stream at path")
+
         self.fail("destroy asdfasdf")
         self.contain("No stream at path")
 
@@ -728,8 +739,14 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         self.ok("list --detail")
         lines_(self.captured, 7)
 
-        # Delete some
+        # Fail to destroy because intervals still present
-        self.ok("destroy /newton/prep")
+        self.fail("destroy /newton/prep")
+        self.contain("all intervals must be removed")
+        self.ok("list --detail")
+        lines_(self.captured, 7)
+
+        # Destroy for real
+        self.ok("destroy -R /newton/prep")
         self.ok("list")
         self.match("/newton/raw uint16_6\n"
                    "/newton/zzz/rawnotch uint16_9\n")
@@ -740,7 +757,8 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
 
         self.ok("destroy /newton/raw")
         self.ok("create /newton/raw uint16_6")
-        self.ok("destroy /newton/raw")
+        # Specify --remove with no data
+        self.ok("destroy --remove /newton/raw")
         self.ok("list")
         self.match("")
 
@@ -815,7 +833,7 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
 
         # Now recreate the data one more time and make sure there are
         # fewer files.
-        self.ok("destroy /newton/prep")
+        self.ok("destroy --remove /newton/prep")
         self.fail("destroy /newton/prep") # already destroyed
         self.ok("create /newton/prep float32_8")
         os.environ['TZ'] = "UTC"
@@ -826,14 +844,16 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         for (dirpath, dirnames, filenames) in os.walk(testdb):
             nfiles += len(filenames)
         lt_(nfiles, 50)
-        self.ok("destroy /newton/prep") # destroy again
+        self.ok("destroy -R /newton/prep") # destroy again
 
     def test_14_remove_files(self):
         # Test BulkData's ability to remove when data is split into
         # multiple files.  Should be a fairly comprehensive test of
         # remove functionality.
+        # Also limit max_removals, to cover more functionality.
         server_stop()
-        server_start(bulkdata_args = { "file_size" : 920, # 23 rows per file
+        server_start(max_removals = 4321,
+                     bulkdata_args = { "file_size" : 920, # 23 rows per file
                                        "files_per_dir" : 3 })
 
         # Insert data.  Just for fun, insert out of order
@@ -974,8 +994,8 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         self.match("[ Thu, 01 Jan 2004 00:00:00.000000 +0000 -"
                    "> Sat, 01 Jan 2005 00:00:00.000000 +0000 ]\n")
 
-        self.ok("destroy /diff/1")
+        self.ok("destroy -R /diff/1")
-        self.ok("destroy /diff/2")
+        self.ok("destroy -R /diff/2")
 
     def test_16_rename(self):
         # Test renaming.  Force file size smaller so we get more files
@@ -1039,7 +1059,7 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
         self.fail("rename /foo/bar /xxx/yyy/zzz/www")
         self.contain("path is subdir of existing node")
         self.ok("rename /foo/bar /xxx/yyy/mmm")
-        self.ok("destroy /xxx/yyy/zzz")
+        self.ok("destroy -R /xxx/yyy/zzz")
         check_path("xxx", "yyy", "mmm")
 
         # Extract it at the final path
@@ -1047,7 +1067,7 @@ class TestCmdline(object):
                 "--end '2012-03-23 10:04:01'")
         eq_(self.captured, extract_before)
 
-        self.ok("destroy /xxx/yyy/mmm")
+        self.ok("destroy -R /xxx/yyy/mmm")
 
         # Make sure temporary rename dirs weren't left around
         for (dirpath, dirnames, filenames) in os.walk(testdb):